United States · in depth
Who controls your health record in the United States? Mostly not you.
The US scores 48 out of 100 on health record rights, tied for 55th of 198. You have a legal right to a copy, but little say over who sees your record, and apps outside HIPAA can share or sell your health data.
The eight rights, against the typical country and four peers
The US scores above the typical country on 7 of the 8 rights. It scores below all four comparison countries on 3: control over who sees it, privacy and security and protection from sale and ads. Access to the record and control over it count most, 20% each.
| Right and weight | US | Typical | UK | Canada | Australia | Germany | Position on a 0 to 100 scale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 48 | 39 | 59 | 52 | 66 | 63 | |
| Getting your full record 20% | 50 | 40 to 45 | 66 | 50 | 70 | 64 | |
| Control over who sees it 20% | 35 | 30 | 52 | 55 | 68 | 66 | |
| Privacy and security 15% | 50 | 45 | 56 | 58 | 62 | 58 | |
| One record across your care 15% | 60 | 38 | 62 | 50 | 70 | 66 | |
| Protection from sale and ads 10% | 38 | 45 | 60 | 45 | 65 | 70 | |
| Doctors see it when treating you 10% | 55 | 33 to 34 | 60 | 55 | 66 | 62 | |
| Your say over research use 5% | 49 | 46 | 64 | 49 | 50 | 50 | |
| Rules for AI in your care 5% | 56 | 30 | 55 | 56 | 55 | 50 |
- Can I get a copy?Yes. They must act within 30 days.Or 60 with one extension. They may charge only a cost-based fee.The rule in full
- Who decides who sees it?Doctors, hospitals and insurers decide.They can share it for care, payment and running their own operations without asking you.What you can limit
- Can apps sell it?HIPAA does not stop them.It does not cover a health app you download yourself. Data with identifiers removed is outside HIPAA and can be sold.What HIPAA does not cover
- What about AI?Yes, but HHS has proposed removing one rule.In December 2025, HHS proposed removing the rule that health record systems must show who built a predictive tool and its known risks.Rules for AI in care
- Is any of this enforced?6 penalties or settlements over slow records in two years.3 civil money penalties and 3 settlements from October 1, 2024 to October 1, 2026, totaling $592,500. No information blocking penalties published through May 27, 2026.None of this feeds the score.The enforcement record
- Can I sue?That depends on your state.In 11 of the 50 states, a law lets you sue over misuse of your health records; in 31 more, only in a narrow case, such as a data breach.There is no state total and no state rank.What your state adds
How the US scores in 2026
In 2026, the United States scores 48 out of 100 on a person's right to see, control and share their own health record. That puts it in a tie for 55th of 198 countries and territories; allowing for scoring error, it could rank anywhere from 45th to 80th. It sits in the Mixed band (45 to 64).
The US scores above the typical country (39 out of 100), but below the UK (59/100), Canada (52/100), Australia (66/100) and Germany (63/100). Its two lowest scores are control over who sees it (35) and protection from sale and ads (38). They are its only scores in the Weak range. Both are below all four of those countries.
Not legal advice. This page explains how our index scores the United States and what US law says, in plain English. Laws change, and your situation may differ. For advice about your own records, ask a lawyer or the agency named in each section.
Who holds the keys: doctors, hospitals and insurers. Each keeps its own records, and there is no national health record.
On this page:
- The eight rights
- US law in plain English
- Your HIPAA right of access: getting a copy
- Who decides who sees your record
- Information blocking: the Cures Act rule
- Your insurer's data: the Patient Access API
- Connecting records: TEFCA
- What HIPAA does not cover
- Health apps: the FTC and its cases
- Security, breaches and police access
- State laws
- Rules for AI in care
- Research
- The enforcement record
- Sam's story, in pictures
- How fair is 48?
- What would raise the US score
- What your state adds
- Stories, brief and data
US law in plain English
The US has no single national health record and no one privacy law for all health data. Your rights come from several federal laws, each with its own reach, and from state laws that differ from state to state. Each claim below links to the law or the agency page we read. We checked the federal law against those sources on October 3, 2026.
Your HIPAA right of access: getting a copy. Can you get a copy of your record?
Yes. They must act within 30 days, or 60 with one extension.
Under HIPAA, a doctor, hospital or health plan must act on your request for your records within 30 days. It may take one 30-day extension1 (1. 45 CFR 164.524). The right covers your medical and billing records. It does not cover a therapist's separate psychotherapy notes or files prepared for a lawsuit. If you ask for an electronic copy in a form they can readily produce, they must give it to you that way. They may charge only a cost-based fee: the labor of copying, supplies, postage, and a summary if you agree to one.
If you need your record or got no answer, one page lists who to contact: Who to contact in the United States. Not legal advice.
Step by step, with what you can get, what a copy can cost and what each of the 50 states and DC adds: how to get your medical records. And state by state: how long medical records are kept, how to get old medical records from a closed practice, how to get a deceased parent's medical records, and medical records fees by state.
The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) enforces this right. It has brought 55 right of access cases since 20192 (2. HHS, August 27, 2026). HHS plans to propose a change to the response time in November 2026. The plan does not say whether the time would get shorter or longer3 (3. federal rulemaking agenda).
Who decides who sees your record. Can they share it without asking you?
Yes, for care, payment and running their own operations. You can ask them to limit it, but they can say no.
HIPAA lets providers and health plans share your records for treatment, payment and their own operations without asking you4 (4. 45 CFR 164.506). You can ask them to limit sharing, but they can say no. One exception: if you pay for an item in full yourself, they must keep it from your health plan when you ask5 (5. 45 CFR 164.522). You can get a list of disclosures from the past six years, but it leaves out sharing for treatment, payment and operations6 (6. 45 CFR 164.528). So it does not show who saw your record in routine care. Records from substance use treatment have extra protection. Since February 16, 2026, one signed consent can cover future uses for treatment, payment and operations7 (7. 42 CFR Part 2 rule).
Information blocking: the Cures Act rule. Can someone block you from your electronic record?
It can be against the law. Providers face cuts in Medicare programs, not money penalties.
Under the 21st Century Cures Act rule, it can be against the law to block your access to your electronic health information. The rule calls this "information blocking." It covers providers, health IT developers and health information networks. A practice counts if it is likely to interfere with getting, sharing or using electronic health information8 (8. 45 CFR Part 171). A provider breaks the rule only if it knows the practice is unreasonable. There are ten exceptions, such as preventing harm, privacy, security and requests that are not feasible. One exception allows some fees. It does not allow a fee for viewing your own records online.
Health IT developers and networks can face penalties of up to $1 million per violation, the figure in the law before inflation adjustments9 (9. 42 U.S.C. 300jj-52). Providers do not face these money penalties. Since July 2024, a hospital or clinician found to be blocking can instead face what HHS calls "disincentives" in Medicare programs10 (10. HHS rule, 2024). In September 2025, HHS announced what it called a "crackdown" on information blocking11 (11. HHS). As of May 27, 2026, the HHS Inspector General had published no information blocking penalties12 (12. OIG).
Your insurer's data: the Patient Access API. Which plans must share it?
Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, CHIP and plans on the federal marketplace.
Since January 1, 2021, some health plans have had to offer a Patient Access API13 (13. 42 CFR 422.119, 431.60 and 457.730; 45 CFR 156.221; the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, CMS). An API, or application programming interface, is a standard way for apps to get data. Here it lets patients get their plan's data electronically. The rule covers Medicare Advantage plans, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and plans on the federal marketplace. A 2024 rule, CMS-0057-F, adds prior authorization data to it. It also requires two more connections, one to your doctors (Provider Access) and one between insurers (payer-to-payer), mostly by January 1, 202714 (14. CMS-0057-F). You will be able to opt out of the Provider Access exchange15 (15. CMS fact sheet).
Connecting records: TEFCA. Do health networks share records with each other?
Yes, through a national framework called TEFCA. Some apps that fetch your records through it may not be covered by HIPAA.
TEFCA (the Trusted Exchange Framework and Common Agreement) is a national framework that lets health networks exchange records with each other. HHS says the number of records exchanged through it grew from 10 million to more than 1 billion in less than a year16 (16. HHS, June 2026). There are 11 networks designated to carry TEFCA exchange17 (17. list), and 22 apps are listed to fetch records for patients who ask18 (18. list). Some of these apps may not be covered by HIPAA, so once your data reaches them, other rules may apply.
What HIPAA does not cover. Does HIPAA cover health apps?
Not the ones you download yourself. Those, fitness trackers and data brokers sit outside it.
HIPAA covers doctors, hospitals, health plans and the companies that work for them. It does not cover a health app you download yourself, a fitness tracker or smartwatch, or a data broker that buys and sells data. Inside HIPAA, marketing and any sale of your health information need your written permission19 (19. 45 CFR 164.508). But data with identifiers removed ("de-identified") is outside HIPAA and can be sold20 (20. 45 CFR 164.514).
Health apps: the FTC and its cases. Who protects your data in a health app?
Often the FTC. Its rule requires notice, not your consent for each use.
For many health apps, the Federal Trade Commission's Health Breach Notification Rule applies instead. The FTC says the rule can apply to health apps and similar technologies21 (21. FTC, 2024). Since July 29, 2024, a "breach" under the rule includes sharing your data without your permission, not only a hack22 (22. 16 CFR Part 318). The rule requires notice. It does not require your consent for each use.
The FTC's first case under the rule was GoodRx in 2023: the company was barred from sharing health data for ads and paid a $1.5 million civil penalty23 (23. FTC). The FTC also uses its general power against deception. It barred BetterHelp from sharing health data for ads and required it to pay $7.8 million24 (24. 2023, FTC). It required Flo Health to get users' consent before sharing their health data25 (25. 2021, FTC). These orders bind one company each. The enforcement record below counts the FTC's health privacy cases.
Security, breaches and police access. Can the police get your records?
Yes: with a court order, a subpoena or some administrative requests.
HIPAA requires breach reporting, and the HHS breach portal lists every large breach. A major update to the HIPAA Security Rule was proposed in January 2025; the federal agenda now targets a final rule in July 202726 (26. rulemaking agenda). Police can get records with a court order or a subpoena, and also with an administrative request when the law requires a response27 (27. 45 CFR 164.512). A 2024 rule that added protection for reproductive health records was mostly struck down by a federal court on June 18, 202528 (28. HHS; court docket). The official online copy of the regulations still shows the struck-down rule. The court's ruling is what counts.
State laws. Does your state add rules?
Some do. Washington, for one, covers health data outside HIPAA. Each state and DC has its own page.
Some states add their own rules. Washington's My Health My Data Act covers health data outside HIPAA. Since March 31, 2024, no one may sell a person's consumer health data there without the person's signed permission; small businesses had until June 30, 202429 (29. RCW 19.373.070). New York's legislature passed a similar bill, which was vetoed on December 19, 202530 (30. NY Senate). Texas requires electronic health records to be stored in the United States from January 1, 202631 (31. Texas SB 1188). Our national score credits state law only in a few places; the state layer below will look at every state.
Rules for AI in care. Will those rules stay?
Not all of them. HHS has proposed removing one and plans changes to another.
The FDA regulates AI tools that count as medical devices and lists about 1,600 of them32 (32. FDA). Its final guidance from August 2025 lets makers plan approved updates in advance33 (33. FDA guidance). HHS lists two rules as in force. Certified health record systems must show users who built a predictive tool, what it is for, its known risks and what data trained it. HHS proposed removing those requirements in December 2025; no final rule had been published when we checked34 (34. HTI-5 proposal). Since May 2025, providers that take federal funds must look for decision support tools that use race, color, national origin, sex, age or disability. They must also reduce the risk of bias these tools create35 (35. 45 CFR 92.210). HHS plans to propose changes to this rule in February 2027. In Texas, practitioners must review records made with AI and tell patients when they use AI for diagnosis36 (36. Texas SB 1188).
Research. Can researchers use your record without asking?
Yes, with a review board's waiver. There is no general way to opt out.
A review board can let researchers use your records without your permission. The privacy risk must be minimal. The research must also be impractical to do without the waiver or without the data37 (37. 45 CFR 164.512). A limited data set, with names and other direct identifiers removed, can be shared for research under a data use agreement. De-identified data needs no consent38 (38. 45 CFR 164.514). There is no general way to opt out of research use. Research that federal agencies fund or run follows the Common Rule, which requires informed consent or a board waiver and allows "broad consent" to future research39 (39. 45 CFR 46.116). Research funded by the National Institutes of Health that meets set criteria automatically has a Certificate of Confidentiality, a federal protection for research records40 (40. NIH).
The enforcement record
From October 1, 2024 to October 1, 2026, OCR announced 6 right of access actions (3 civil money penalties and 3 settlements), totaling $592,500. The Inspector General had published no information blocking penalties. Over the same period there were 1,546 reports of large breaches, about 2 every day, and 34 of them each hit a million people or more. Together they list 234.9 million exposed records of people; one person can appear in several, so this is not a count of different people. None of this feeds the score.
| Who acts | What we counted | In the window | Since the start (includes the window) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HHS Office for Civil Rights (OCR) | Right of access actions: a provider or plan was slow to give patients their records | 6: 3 civil money penalties ($370,000) and 3 settlements ($222,500). Total $592,500. | 55 since the program began in 2019 | OCR list |
| HHS Inspector General | Information blocking penalties published | 0 (through May 27, 2026) | 0 | OIG page |
| HHS health IT office (ONC) complaint portal | Information blocking claims that name a health care provider. Claims received, not findings | 1,042 (Oct 2024 to Jul 2026) | 1,938 since April 5, 2021 | Claims data |
| Same portal, all claims | Claims filed by patients, whatever organization they name. One claim can name more than one type of organization, so this is not a share of the row above | 900 (Oct 2024 to Jul 2026) | 1,554 | |
| Federal Trade Commission (FTC) | Health privacy cases: every case the FTC files under "Health Privacy", plus Cerebral (a telehealth case we added) | 2 with a new complaint or order: Hims & Hers Health (complaint, pending); Kochava Inc. and Collective Data Solutions. 2 where the only new step was refunds: BetterHelp; Cerebral (refunds for cancellation practices, not health data). | 20 cases | Case pages, linked |
| HHS OCR breach portal | Breaches of 500 or more people, reported by HIPAA-covered organizations | 1,546 reports. 34 affected 1 million people or more. 234,919,800 people listed across all reports; one person can appear in several. Largest: Conduent Business Services LLC, 62,224,658. | Breach portal | |
| California attorney general | Health data privacy cases under state law | 1: Healthline Media LLC, a settlement of $1.55 million (July 1, 2025) | Release | |
| Washington attorney general | Cases under the My Health My Data Act | 0 found | AG page |
| Announced | Organization | Action | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 17, 2024 | Gums Dental Care, LLC, MD | Civil money penalty | $70,000 |
| November 19, 2024 | Rio Hondo Community Mental Health Center, CA | Civil money penalty | $100,000 |
| January 15, 2025 | Memorial Healthcare System, FL | Settlement | $60,000 |
| March 6, 2025 | Oregon Health & Science University, OR | Civil money penalty | $200,000 |
| December 16, 2025 | Concentra, Inc. | Settlement | $112,500 |
| August 27, 2026 | Azul Vision, Inc., CA | Settlement | $50,000 |
| Total | $592,500 | ||
Information blocking claims are complaints received, not findings, and one claim can name more than one type of organization. Breach reports are each organization's own count. The window matches the one our stories use, so older cases such as GoodRx (2023) and the Change Healthcare breach (reported in 2024) are outside it.
Sam's week
Is your health record yours in America?
Follow one week of care, and see who ends up holding what.
Skip the story
1
Meet Sam
A made-up story built from real law, real cases and published studies.
Quick: who do you think controls your health record?
Meet Sam. She lives in the US. One Tuesday, she feels awful at work and heads to urgent care.
That one visit starts a paper trail.

2
You've probably heard...
You've probably heard that your records will soon flow easily to the apps you use.
In July 2025, the federal health agency CMS announced pledges for apps that use "conversational AI assistants" and tools to "kill the clipboard."
So is it really that easy? Let's follow Sam and see.
"promoting a CMS Interoperability Framework to easily and seamlessly share information between patients and providers"
CMS press release, July 30, 2025
"The use of conversational AI assistants to help patients check symptoms, navigate care options, and schedule appointments"
CMS press release, July 30, 2025 (pledged apps)
"health records must flow easily between providers and patients"
HHS press release, June 26, 2026, quoting an HHS official
Quoted word for word from CMS and HHS. These are pledges and plans.
The details
These are pledges, plans and goals, quoted from the government's own announcements. We quote them to show what people are being told. The "So, is it easy?" step weighs them against the law.
Sources: CMS press release, July 30, 2025; HHS press release, June 26, 2026.

3
Who has a piece?
By Friday, six places have a piece of Sam's record. Tap each one to see what it holds.
Sam is not unusual. Lots of people have more than one patient portal (a website or app for seeing your record).
So who is in charge of all these pieces?
ASTP/ONC Data Brief 77, 2024 survey
- Urgent care: The notes from Sam's visit.
- Sam's doctor: The follow-up visit.
- The hospital lab: Sam's test results.
- The pharmacy: Sam's prescription.
- The insurer: The bill, with a code for what was wrong.
- The fitness app: Heart rate and sleep. Most apps sit outside the privacy law.
The details
The pieces in Sam's story are typical examples, not a list of every place that may hold a record.
The 59% comes from ASTP/ONC Data Brief 77: "more than half of individuals nationally (59%) had multiple online medical records or patient portals in 2024."
Sources: ASTP/ONC Data Brief 77, 2024 survey.
| Urgent care | Doctor | Hospital lab | Pharmacy | Insurer | Fitness app | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sam | copy in 30 days | copy in 30 days | copy in 30 days | copy in 30 days | copy in 30 days | outside HIPAA |

4
Sam asks for a copy
Sam asks for a copy. The federal health privacy law, called HIPAA, says she gets one within 30 days, or 60 if they need more time.
But Sam's doctor, hospital and insurer can share the record for care, for payment and to run their business. They don't have to ask.
Sam can see her record. Steering it is another matter.
Health Record Rights Index, data as of October 2, 2026
Black dot: the US. Ringed dots: the UK, Canada, Australia and Germany, four other large, high-income countries; three of them are federal, like the US. Gray tick: the typical country of 198 countries and territories; gray bar: the middle half. The numbers 25, 45, 65 and 85 split our scores into bands, from weakest to strongest. Data as of October 2, 2026.
The details
Some other uses, like marketing or selling the record, need Sam's written permission. Others, like public health reporting and some court orders, do not.
Sam can ask them to limit sharing, and they can say no. One exception: if Sam paid for care in full herself, she can keep it from her health plan.
Who owns the record? Sam's doctor or hospital holds it. New Hampshire's law says the medical information in it is the patient's property. That does not change who HIPAA lets see it. We have not checked other states on this.
Sources: Our United States page in the Health Record Rights Index, version 1.0 (SuperTruth, 2026), data as of October 2, 2026 (45 CFR 164.506, 164.508, 164.522, 164.524); N.H. RSA 332-I:1.

5
The fitness app
Sam's fitness app knows her heart rate and her sleep. Apps like fitness and period trackers usually sit outside the privacy law.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) can step in when it believes an app shared health data it promised to keep private.
It has, more than once. These three cases ended in settlements, not court rulings.
| Company | Money | Order |
|---|---|---|
| GoodRx | $1.5 million civil penalty | settled by order, 2023 |
| BetterHelp | $7.8 million | settled by order, 2023 |
| Premom | $100,000 civil penalty (plus $100,000 to three states) | settled by order, 2023 |
Three examples, chosen by us, of the 20 health-privacy cases in our US enforcement record. Others, such as Flo Health, are in the full record. None involves the companies on the cards in the next step. Order text: GoodRx, BetterHelp, Premom.
The details
Sam's app is made up. The three cases are real. In each, the FTC charged the company with sharing health data for advertising, and the case was settled by an order in 2023. Each company "neither admits nor denies any of the allegations in the Complaint," in the words of its order.
We chose these three as examples. They are 3 of the 20 health-privacy cases in our US enforcement record. Others, such as Flo Health, are in the full record.
Sources: Our US enforcement record (FTC case pages), built October 3, 2026.

6
When your name comes off, the data keeps going
Now strip Sam's name and the other details the law lists, like her address and birth date, out of her record.
Once it passes one of the law's two tests for this, the privacy law no longer limits selling it. Some big companies make the systems that hold health records. Others work with records that have the names taken off.
Here is what a few of them report. None of these figures says how much comes from patient data.
Price paid once, to buy a company
One part of a company: its sales for one year
A regulator's finding
From the paper's disclosures: "Three of the authors, Jason Alan Snyder, Robert P. Hill IV and Dustin Raney, are officers of SuperTruth Inc., which sells health data verification products. The fourth, Leann Sims, is Chief Executive Officer of MedSync, a US health information exchange that works with SuperTruth. SuperTruth funded this work and controlled its design, analysis, writing and the decision to publish." And: "The position in Section 13 aligns with what SuperTruth sells."
Protection from sale and ads. Black dot: the US (38 out of 100). Ringed: the UK, Canada, Australia, Germany. Asterisks (*): low confidence, where 4 or more of the 8 rights rest on weak evidence (66 of 198 countries and territories). The numbers 25, 45, 65 and 85 split our scores into bands, from weakest to strongest. Data as of October 2, 2026.
The details
Inside HIPAA, selling a record that names you needs your written permission. Once data meets one of HIPAA's two tests for removing identity, HIPAA no longer limits sharing or selling it. Other laws may still apply.
These are separate facts of different kinds, so we do not add them up. The filings do not say how much of each figure comes from patient data. Nothing here says any company on these cards broke the law.
Sources: company filings and releases: Oracle Form 10-K, fiscal 2022, Note 2, Roche press release, February 15, 2018, IQVIA Form 10-K, 2025, UnitedHealth Group Form 10-K, 2025; FTC, Data Brokers: A Call for Transparency and Accountability, 2014; Health Record Rights Index, version 1.0 (SuperTruth, 2026), data as of October 2, 2026: every score with the laws and official pages behind it, on each country's page (for example the United States and Finland); how we scored.

7
A mistake in the chart
| Right | Where each scores, 0 to 100 | This step's scores |
|---|---|---|
| Your copy | Getting your full record: US 50 out of 100, Finland 76 out of 100. The typical score is 40 to 45 out of 100. | |
| Who sees it | Control over who sees it: US 35 out of 100, Finland 74 out of 100. The typical score is 30 out of 100. | |
| Privacy | Privacy and security: US 50 out of 100, Finland 62 out of 100. The typical score is 45 out of 100. | |
| Joined-up record | One record across your care: US 60 out of 100, Finland 82 out of 100. The typical score is 38 out of 100. | |
| Sale and ads | Protection from sale and ads: US 38 out of 100, Finland 68 out of 100. The typical score is 45 out of 100. | |
| Doctors see it | Doctors see it when treating you: US 55 out of 100, Finland 76 out of 100. The typical score is 33 to 34 out of 100. | |
| Research | Your say over research use: US 49 out of 100, Finland 58 out of 100. The typical score is 46 out of 100. | |
| AI rules | Rules for AI in your care: US 56 out of 100, Finland 50 out of 100. The typical score is 30 out of 100. | |
| 050100 |
Now suppose Sam's chart has a mistake, like the wrong allergy. It happens: in one survey, about 1 in 5 patients who read their notes said they spotted what they thought was a mistake.
Fixing it starts with seeing it. And getting a record can take a long time.
Some waited more than a year.
Cases the federal health privacy office (OCR) acted on, November 2024 to August 2026, where OCR states the wait, in months from the request. Not typical waits. Solid line: the wait OCR states; dotted: OHSU by OCR's own dates. Arrow: OCR says only "more than". Notch: OCR says "almost". Source: HHS OCR releases, in our US enforcement record.
The details
The survey: 22,889 patients at three US health systems who had read their notes answered questions in 2017. 21.1% said they found what they thought was a mistake (Bell and others, JAMA Network Open, 2020).
The waits are cases the federal health privacy office (OCR) acted on, not typical waits. OCR has taken 55 actions against slow or refused record requests since 2019.
From October 2024 to July 2026, patients filed 900 claims that someone blocked them from their electronic records. These are claims, not findings. As of May 27, 2026, HHS's inspector general had published no penalty for blocking.
Sources: Bell and others, JAMA Network Open, 2020; Our US enforcement record (HHS OCR releases; ASTP information-blocking data), built October 3, 2026.
See the numbers
| Right | US: score out of 100 | Finland: score out of 100 | Typical country of the 198 countries and territories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Getting your full record | 50 | 76 | 40 to 45 |
| Control over who sees it | 35 | 74 | 30 |
| Privacy and security | 50 | 62 | 45 |
| One record across your care | 60 | 82 | 38 |
| Protection from sale and ads | 38 | 68 | 45 |
| Doctors see it when treating you | 55 | 76 | 33 to 34 |
| Your say over research use | 49 | 58 | 46 |
| Rules for AI in your care | 56 | 50 | 30 |

8
A computer reads it too
Hospitals now run AI tools on charts like Sam's. A 2021 study found a widely used alert for sepsis (a dangerous reaction to infection) missed two in three cases at one hospital system. A newer version did better in a 2026 study, but still raised many false alarms.
So how strong are the rules for AI in your care?
On rules for AI in care, the US scores 56 out of 100. The typical country scores 30 out of 100.
Black dot: the US. Ringed: the UK, Canada, Australia and Germany. Gray tick: the typical country of 198 countries and territories; gray bar: the middle half. Data as of October 2, 2026.
The details
Wong and others, JAMA Internal Medicine, 2021: one hospital system, records from 2018 to 2019; at the alert level studied, the tool missed 67% of sepsis cases.
Wong and others, JAMA Network Open, 2026: the newer version at four systems, records from 2023 to 2025; better at telling cases apart, but many false alarms.
Obermeyer and others, Science, 2019: a tool that picked patients for extra help used predicted costs as a stand-in for health need. So it flagged fewer Black patients than White patients who were just as sick.
We chose these as well-known examples. They are not a review of how well medical AI works.
Sources: Wong and others, JAMA Internal Medicine, 2021; Wong and others, JAMA Network Open, 2026; Obermeyer and others, Science, 2019; Our United States page in the Health Record Rights Index, version 1.0 (SuperTruth, 2026), data as of October 2, 2026.

9
Guess the score
Your turn. Out of 100, what do you think the US scores overall on health record rights? Drag to guess.
Then follow one of the eight scores behind it back to its sources.
The answer: the US scores 48 out of 100.
- The scoreGetting your full record: 50 out of 100 · United States
- The band it falls inMixed, 45 to 64: some rights. They work for some people.
- Our summary, not a quoteUnder 45 CFR 164.524 a provider or health plan must act within 30 days, with one 30-day extension.
- Source 1 of 445 CFR 164.524 Access of individuals to protected health information (eCFR) · undated in our records (the page has no date; we checked the quote against the September 1, 2026 version) · open the source
- The law says
... an individual has a right of access to inspect and obtain a copy of protected health information about the individual in a designated record set ...
We checked this word for word against a saved copy of the official federal rules page (eCFR, 45 CFR 164.524, version September 1, 2026). The rule lists exceptions. - How sureNo second agent has re-scored the US on access yet. When a second agent re-scored other countries without seeing our scores, it agreed with us less often than on most rights: 0.68 on a scale where 1 means full agreement.
| Category | Score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Getting your full record | 50 | × 20% |
| Control over who sees it | 35 | × 20% |
| Privacy and security | 50 | × 15% |
| One record across your care | 60 | × 15% |
| Protection from sale and ads | 38 | × 10% |
| Doctors see it when treating you | 55 | × 10% |
| Your say over research use | 49 | × 5% |
| Rules for AI in your care | 56 | × 5% |
| Overall | 48 |
Sum of score × weight: 4,805 / 100 = 48.05, which rounds to 48.
Data as of October 2, 2026 · data version 7d9d4873c5fc (lets you check you have the same data we do)
We reran the ranking 10,000 times. Each time, we added a random nudge to every score, typically about 5 points, and shifted the weights. The size comes from how much a second agent disagreed with us when it scored without seeing our scores. The US landed between 45th and 80th in 90% of runs. This does not test our choice of categories or who holds the keys.
The details
Each of the eight scores is a judgment. AI agents read laws and other public sources and suggested each score against a written rulebook. A second AI agent checked each country. The four authors ruled on every finding that check raised.
Once the eight scores are set, the overall score is plain arithmetic: the same numbers in always give the same answer out. That proves the math, not the scores.
We use chance in one place: to show how far a rank could move if our scoring is off. Like a weather forecast, it gives the odds.
Sources: Health Record Rights Index, version 1.0 (SuperTruth, 2026), data as of October 2, 2026: every score with the laws and official pages behind it, on each country's page (for example the United States and Finland); how we scored; rank simulations: 10,000 runs that allow for scoring error and weight choices, in the paper; the eCFR text of 45 CFR 164.524.

10
Sam moves
Sam takes a new job and moves to Washington, DC. The federal law moves with her.
DC adds its own laws on top. We checked them, and the laws of all 50 states.
We don't give states a single score. Each state has its own answers to these seven questions.
What Washington, DC adds · every state
The seven questions we asked for each of the 50 states and Washington, DC:
1 Do apps and wearables need your OK before sharing health data?
None in force (no law found)
17 of 50Same answer in 17 of the 50 states.
2 Do you get a copy faster or free in some cases?
Neither
Same answer in 13 of the 50 states.
Not drawn as a map: the answer lives in the details (days, fees and free cases).
3 Can you say no to sharing through a health information exchange (a network that passes records between doctors)?
Opt-out
33 of 50Same answer in 33 of the 50 states.
4 Are some sensitive records, like mental health or HIV, given extra rules?
Yes, for all four kinds: reproductive health, mental health, HIV and genetic records each have a specific rule in force.
Not drawn as a map and not counted: a map of these rules would be read as a political map, which this study does not make.
5 Can you sue if your records are misused?
Narrow case only
31 of 50Same answer in 31 of the 50 states.
6 Must you be told if health data leaks in a breach?
Medical and insurance data
21 of 50Same answer in 21 of the 50 states.
7 Are there rules for AI used in your care?
No rules (no law found)
21 of 50Same answer in 21 of the 50 states.
The details
Each state's page links every law we read, with its date. There is no state total and no state rank.
imaware, an affiliate of SuperTruth, provides testing services under agreements with some US state governments. No state paid for this study or had any say in it.
Sources: Our state study plan and rulebook (50 states and Washington, DC).

11
So, is it easy?
So who controls Sam's record? Mostly the doctors, hospitals and insurers that hold it. Sam can get a copy, and she can ask them to limit sharing, but they can usually say no. Her fitness app sits outside the privacy law, her chart can hold a mistake, and her doctors' systems don't always talk.
Some of the promise is already law: since 2021, many insurers (Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and marketplace plans) have had to let patients pull their records into an app. And in a national survey, 76% of US hospitals did all four key ways of sharing records in 2025 (sending, receiving, finding and adding outside records), up from 70% in 2023.
The pledges are real. So are the gaps. Our view: an AI tool can only work with the record it's given.
- You can see your record, but doctors, hospitals and insurers can share it for care, payment and business without asking.
- Most apps sit outside the privacy law.
- Once data passes the law's tests for removing identity, the privacy law no longer limits selling it.
- Charts can hold mistakes, and getting a record can take a long time.
- AI tools read whatever record they are given.
- State laws can add to this. See what yours adds.
Hospital sharing figures: ASTP/ONC Quick Stat, Electronic Health Information Exchange by Hospitals (AHA survey, 2023 and 2025). Insurer apps: CMS Patient Access rule, in our US file. Records exchanged through TEFCA: HHS.
The details
That last line is our view, not a finding. It matches what SuperTruth sells (paper, section 12 and disclosures).
In less than a year, records exchanged through TEFCA, a nationwide network set up under HHS rules, grew "from 10 million to more than 1 billion" (HHS, June 26, 2026).
Sources: ASTP/ONC Quick Stat on hospital exchange (2025); HHS press release, June 26, 2026; the steps above.

12
How much do you control?
Three quick questions about US law. No sign-up. Your answers are not stored.
Then check our work, and tell us what we got wrong.
Your answers stay on this page. We count only that the quiz was started and finished, and which result it gave, never your answers. Sharing sends what the law allows, never your answers.
- Students: follow one score back to its source.
- Researchers: the data (DOI) · the paper (DOI) · the paper on SSRN · the code
- Reporters: the press kit, or press@supertruth.ai
- Everyone: tell us what we got wrong · see every change we have made
How fair is 48?
This section tests whether the index treats the US the same way as four similar countries. A separate automated review, run by an AI agent, looked for every way the US score could be too high or too low, category by category, against the UK, Canada, Australia and Germany (our own fairness check, run by an AI agent on October 3, 2026; not yet published). Here is what it found.
The audit found the band holds. Under every way of treating the countries evenly that the audit tried, the US stays Mixed. Where the scoring rules give exact steps (access, control, research and AI), the US score holds up, and the US is scored by the same steps as Canada.
The audit found the score slightly low. Where the scoring rules have no exact steps (privacy and protection from commercial use), the comparison does not treat every country the same way, and mostly this works against the US:
- The US commercial score leaves out how the FTC enforces its health breach rule. Canada's regulator has no similar power. The UK's commercial score did not look at apps or data brokers.
- The US privacy score counts people affected by breaches. Canada and Australia count incidents, and the UK and Germany give no national breach figure. Only the US has a public register that counts people.
- Only the US and Australia were checked for police access to records.
- Canada was scored on the laws of four provinces. The US was scored on federal law, with state law in only a few places and none for control.
Applying the fixes the audit could verify, the US would score 49.55, which rounds to 50: tied for 51st of 198 countries and territories, instead of tied for 55th. That is still Mixed. Applying only the fixes that lower the US score gives 47. The highest score the audit argues for, counting fixes it could not yet verify, is 54. Our own computed score range for the US (the middle 90% of simulations that allow for scoring error) is 43 to 53.
Comparisons that are too fragile to quote. On protection from sale and ads, the US (38 out of 100) and Chile (42/100) are the two lowest OECD scores, 4 points apart. That is inside our 5-point step, so "last in the OECD" is not a finding. Nor is 48 a precise number: read it with its range.
The US score will not change in this version. The audit proposes 4 written rules. They cover how to score countries without a national system and using one unit for breaches. They also say proposed laws earn no credit or penalty, and areas no one checked count as missing. The US score moves only in version 1.1 of the index, when those rules are written and applied to every country, not to the US alone.
What would raise the US score
These are the legal changes the published scoring rules reward, at the low end of each step. This is a description of the scoring rules, not a recommendation. A proposed law earns nothing until it is in force.
- Control over who sees it 20% · now 35
A working way to say no to sharing in care (an opt-out or opt-in), or a log you can see of who opened your record in care, including routine care. Either one puts control at 40 to 55. Both, plus finer choices about who sees what: 60 to 80. At the low end, this adds 1.0 points to the overall score. Both, plus finer choices, add 5.0. - Getting your full record 20% · now 50
A national portal that shows part of the record (a summary, prescriptions and lab results) to most residents: 60 to 75. At the low end, this adds 2.0 points to the overall score. - Protection from sale and ads 10% · now 38
A privacy law that covers health data held outside HIPAA, by apps, wearables and data brokers, with limits on selling it or using it for ads. This right has no numbered step in the scoring rules yet; reaching the Mixed range starts at 45. At the low end, this adds 0.7 points to the overall score. - Your say over research use 5% · now 49
A general way to opt out of research use of your record, honored in practice: 55 to 70. At the low end, this adds 0.3 points to the overall score.
All four together, each at the low end of its step, would give about 52 (tied for 47th on today's data). That is still Mixed. The next band, Strong, starts at 65, so it would take more than these changes at their lowest.
What your state adds
We read the laws of the 50 states and Washington, DC on seven questions, on October 3, 2026. In 28 of the 50 states, a law in force requires your OK before at least some apps or other businesses outside HIPAA use or share your health data. Each state has its own page, with every law quoted, dated and linked. State laws add to the federal floor. The United States score in the world index rates only federal law and national systems, so these state profiles do not change it. There is no state total and no state rank.
How federal and state law fit together: two layers, in one picture
This study covers the 50 states and Washington, DC. It does not cover the US territories (Puerto Rico, Guam, the US Virgin Islands, the Northern Mariana Islands and American Samoa).
Real cases from the US, the brief and the data
What people report
11 published accounts from the US, from regulators, courts and the news, sit beside the score without changing it.
- August 19, 2026 Health records company confirms data of 3.75 million patients stolen in breach Yahoo News (TechCrunch), admitted by the organization
- August 12, 2026 Billing software vendor confirms theft of insurance and claims data for 3.8 million people Insurance Business, admitted by the organization
- July 29, 2026 Federal and state regulators sue telehealth company over sharing health details with advertisers U.S. Federal Trade Commission, allegation, not proven
- December 16, 2025 Six requests and more than a year before a patient got his records U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, regulator or court finding
- September 30, 2025 Care provider posted patient stories online without written permission U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, regulator or court finding
- July 1, 2025 Health website shared article titles that could reveal a reader's diagnosis California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General, regulator or court finding
- April 2025 Second round of refunds after counseling service shared users' health answers with advertisers U.S. Federal Trade Commission, regulator or court finding
- March 6, 2025 Patient's full records arrived more than two years after her representative first asked U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, regulator or court finding
- January 24, 2025 Insurer confirms health data of about 190 million Americans hit in one attack TechCrunch, admitted by the organization
- January 15, 2025 Patient asked by mail, phone and portal, then waited about nine months U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, regulator or court finding
- November 18, 2024 Patient asked for her records in writing and waited seven months for them U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights, regulator or court finding
Open the United States on the globe · Real cases from every country
More on the United States
- One-page US brief, with every source
- The paper (DOI)
- The data (DOI)
- Scores (CSV)
- Sources (CSV)
- Everything (JSON) (the three downloads are under CC BY 4.0, except the quoted words and source titles they contain)
- How we score
Something wrong on this page? Tell us.
Teaching this story? A free one-period lesson plan
Built by SuperTruth, which checks whether a record can be trusted before an AI acts on it. About SuperTruth · How we used AI · Follow changes
Health Record Rights Index, version 1.0, by SuperTruth. Everything here comes from public information: laws, agency pages, court records and published news. SuperTruth built this index and sells health data verification products; no one paid to be included. Research tool, not legal advice. Our scores and our own words are CC BY 4.0; quoted law and source titles stay with their owners.